Peppermint Stick ice cream pint
Peppermint Stick scoop

Peppermint Stick

The first spoonful is cool air and quiet snow. Creamy, smooth, with a flicker of peppermint… bright, but not loud. Then, the crunch: candy pieces that sparkle and disappear. It tastes like winter remembering how to be sweet.

Ships as early as Nov 2

Still family owned since 1870, Graeter's is the last ice cream still crafted in French Pots, 2 ½ gallons at a time.

Star-D Kosher Certified

6-Pints For $84.96 | 12-Pints For $129.96

Ship to multiple addresses? Click here.

French Pot Ice Cream

Graeter's Ice Cream is made the same way Louis and Regina Graeter made it in 1870. By hand. In 2½-gallon French pots. One batch at a time. With high quality ingredients. Like luscious, gourmet chocolate chips. No other ice cream is made this way. No other ice cream tastes this way. This thick. This rich. This irresistibly good.
  • 5 stars: 13 (93%)
  • 4 stars: 0 (0%)
  • 3 stars: 0 (0%)
  • 2 stars: 0 (0%)
  • 1 star: 1 (7%)
L
Laura

My favorite seasonal ice cream. I have to order more before they are out of stock!!

A
A.B.

The best Peppermint ice cream I have ever had! 10/10!!!

K
Karen

Best ice cream in the world!! Peppermint is my favorite!

D
Donna

On time and delicious!

R
Ryan
Disgusting

This is absolutely revolting. Probably the worst ice cream I've ever had. The chunks of peppermint candy all throughout are incredibly nasty.

K
Kel
OMG

This peppermint stick ice cream is hands down THE best I've ever had. Kudos!! It should be a year round flavor!

C
Clutch
Best Seasonal Peppermint Cream Cream

Never had a better peppermint stick ice cream ever! There are higher priced brands that don’t hold a “stick” to Graeter’s.

C
Chris
Best flavor

I look forward to this so much every year. My favorite ice cream! Was it not produced this year? No stores in my area carried peppermint stick this winter

S
Samuel Hyde
Best ice cream around

A shame it is not available year round, but I guess it makes it more special for Christmas.

C
Corry
Best flavor in the world

Hands down the best ice cream and best flavor. Hard to find but when I do I buy 6 pints. Dessert for Christmas dinner. Love that it’s dye free

H
Hop
Yummm, Childhood

Always have been a childhood flavor. We homemade ours and now I think this is sooooo good. I will never turn away. ????????

L
Laura
Peppermint Stick

Where do I begin... this is hands down the best peppermint stick ice cream ever!! I live in the south and were always stuck with Mayfield. When I went on a visit to Ohio a couple years ago fell absolutely in love with this flavor. Now when I'm out running to the store I always make sure to check they have this in stock and if it is I buy everything they have (no matter the amount) Should be all year round it's that delicious and addicting!!

A
Allie
LOVE this flavor.

LOVE this flavor. However, wish it had your chips!! Peppermint chip would be incredible :)

O
Oosapa
Awesome product, hard to find

One of my all-time favorite desserts. Perfectly balanced on the flavor, smooth, and just the right amount of candy cane chunks. The peppermint oil and the Graeters French pot process works very well together. Love it! Sadly, this is one of the most poorly distributed seasonal flavors in the entire portfolio. If I can actually find a store that carries it, it is often sold out. Please pump up the production of this offering and get your reps to push it in more grocery stores!!!