Graeter's Lemon Meringue Pie Ice Cream Pint
Lemon Meringue Pie Scoop

Lemon Meringue Pie

Graeter's Lemon Meringue Pie is incredibly creamy marshmallow lemon ice cream with crumbles of pie crust and bursts of tart lemon candy crunch.

Still family owned since 1870, Graeter's is the last ice cream still crafted in French Pots, 2 ½ gallons at a time.

Star-D Kosher Certified

6-Pints For $84.96 | 12-Pints For $129.96

Ship to multiple addresses? Click here.

French Pot Ice Cream

Graeter's Ice Cream is made the same way Louis and Regina Graeter made it in 1870. By hand. In 2½-gallon French pots. One batch at a time. With high quality ingredients. Like luscious, gourmet chocolate chips. No other ice cream is made this way. No other ice cream tastes this way. This thick. This rich. This irresistibly good.
  • 5 stars: 24 (89%)
  • 4 stars: 1 (4%)
  • 3 stars: 1 (4%)
  • 2 stars: 0 (0%)
  • 1 star: 1 (4%)
A
Anonymous
Fabulous

Fabulous

s
sherry smith
I was surprised at how good this ice cream is

I was surprised at how good this lemon ice cream is. Lemon flavor is pure, and refreshing. NOT that artificial lemon flavoring. Really Good!

A
Anonymous
Not so lemony.

Not so lemony. More pie and meringue flavor than I like. I've learned to avoid when it says pie...but for those who like that taste you'll love it.

A
Anonymous
Very

Very refreshing!

K
Keith &Aisha Moore
It was Pie Not ice cream!

I don't know how you do it!! But again amazing. I was eating creamy cold pie!! Wonderful! Don't stop making these fabulous flavors.

N
Ntritter
Lemon Merengue Pie my favorite after eating

Lemon Merengue Pie my favorite after eating Graeters for 70+ years. Black Raspberry Chip second favorite.

A
Anonymous
it really was the best lemon pie ever but with

it really was the best lemon pie ever but with ice cream as a plus.

R
Ryan Cordova
Amazing in every way

Amazing in every way. Reminds me of the long lost Girl Scout lemon cookies. Why did those have to go away? I’ll tell you why. So this ice cream can bring you back to your childhood. Close your eyes when you’re eating it and it will transport you back into a simpler time on a hot summer day. The birds are singing the kids are playing in the neighborhood with water guns, burgers are on the grill and a cold lemonade is handed to you to quench your thirst. 10/10

A
Anonymous
Light and refreshing

Light and refreshing. I could eat a pint every season.

P
Patrick Christensen
So Glad This Became a Permanent Flavor!

I'm not usually a lemon ice cream person, but my wife wanted to try this one and it's AMAZING! Definitely give it a go even if it's not a flavor you'd normally go for.

A
Anonymous
I’m a die hard classic chocolate chip but I’ve

I’m a die hard classic chocolate chip but I’ve been branching out by trying different flavors. This is pure heaven if you like lemon meringue pie!

A
Anonymous
This is my new favorite

This is my new favorite. Of course I love all the ones with the super chocolate chips but lemon is so good.

T
Tanya Kwiatkowski
Never Received

I am sure the Lemon Meringue Pie tastes great, but sadly, I won't know because it was missing from my order.

F
Frank

Surprisingly my second to least favorite. I love Lemon Meringue! I knew it wouldn’t be spot on, but it certainly had a nice flavor. Nice lemon flavor in the ice cream, not too bitter, but it just didn’t really hit home for me. Im glad i tried it, but i wouldn’t reorder it.

M
Marti Marache - Southern Comfort
Wonderfully smooth and full of fresh pie bites

Wonderfully smooth and full of fresh pie bites.

J
Jose

Amazing Ice cream

C
Christina

Graeter's has some great flavors and this one is top tier if you love pie and the taste of pie and ice cream.

K
Kenneth

Best for lemon lovers everywhere! What delicious frozen treat. It hits all the notes of the pie, but in ice cream! You will fall in love.

K
Kaseycan2
WoW! Lemonlicious!

This lemon meringue ice cream is absolutely delicious. I have never been a big fan for lemon flavorings but this ice cream is outstanding with its flavor, it's texture, and the bonus of the little crunchy bits is fabulous.

I
I love Lemon
Lemon Crunch candies

Omg best ice cream ever but those little tart lemon Crunch candies inside it addicted where and how can I get more of just them I want a bag of them tart lemon Crunch candies please so much and thanks you guys make awesome ice cream

C
Cyndylouwho
Wonderful!

I just got this last night for the first time. It is delightfully tangy, creamy and the bits of crust and the tart lemon clusters give it that magical tart tang! Thank you!

L
Linda
Absurdly Good!

Wow. Everything I hoped for from the description. Brilliant natural flavor, tangy crunches of tart candy, and the bits of graham cracker crust combine in perfect ratios. I’m eating my next bowl with a little marshmallow topping and possibly will torch it like Baked Alaska. Well done, Graeters!

S
Spark
Fabulous!

This is my new favorite, and that’s saying something! So lemony and the bits of pie crust is a delicious addition!

P
PLAYER!HOW?
This Lemon Meringue Pie Ice Cream is the best!

I am writing a series of Children’s books called “The BEEHIVE”. This is an immersive book that will utilize augmented reality, and virtual reality, first of its kind. One of the highlights of the book is the introduction of Lemon Meringue ice cream to a bee and a human child named Toby. When I started writing the book in 2019 there was no Lemon Meringue ice cream mass produced anywhere that I could find! Lots of recipes online to make it yourself and that was it, until you launched it this year March 1, 2024! I am VERY EXCITED AND HAPPY TO THAT LEMON MERINGUE ICE CREAM IS NOW A REALITY!!!!! This is VERY INSPIRING FOR THE LAUNCH OF MY SERIES OF Child literacy books “THE BEEHIVE” Sincerely yours, Howard McKinney