Graeter's Key Lime Pie ice cream in a green container on a bright yellow background
A scoop of Graeter's Key Lime Pie ice cream
an extreme close up of Graeter's key lime pie ice cream, it is a cream yellow color with bits of brown graham cracker crust throughout

Key Lime Pie

Real key lime juice, French Pot® ice cream, and crunchy graham crust pieces. The tartness shows up first.

Still family owned since 1870, Graeter's is the last ice cream still crafted in French Pots, 2 ½ gallons at a time.

Star-D Kosher Certified

6-Pints For $84.96 | 12-Pints For $129.96

Ship to multiple addresses? Click here.

French Pot Ice Cream

Graeter's Ice Cream is made the same way Louis and Regina Graeter made it in 1870. By hand. In 2½-gallon French pots. One batch at a time. With high quality ingredients. Like luscious, gourmet chocolate chips. No other ice cream is made this way. No other ice cream tastes this way. This thick. This rich. This irresistibly good.