• FREE GROUND SHIPPING on ice cream orders for eligible addresses. Next Day Air delivery available for most addresses for only $29.95. VIEW MAP >

Handcrafted Ice CreamValentine's Gift Selection




This item was a seasonal pack and has run out. Check out our Pack Selections page to see other available options.
Shop Pack Selections

Melt your Valentine's heart with handcrafted ice cream and gelato, featuring:

  • Seasonal Cherry Chocolate Chip

  • Seasonal Chocolate Coconut Almond Chocolate Chip

  • Black Raspberry Chocolate Chip

  • Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip

  • Caramel Truffle Gelato

  • Dark Chocolate Mint Crunch

Craft Legacy

French Pot Ice Cream

Graeter’s Ice Cream is made the same way Louis and Regina Graeter made it in 1870. By hand. In 2½-gallon French pots. One batch at a time. With natural ingredients. Like luscious, gourmet chocolate chips. No other ice cream is made this way. No other ice cream tastes this way. This thick. This rich. This irresistibly good.


Ingredients, nutritional information and allergens varies by flavor. To get the specific nutritional information, please visit our nutritional information page.

We use good manufacturing practices to segregate allergens and avoid cross-contact with flavors that contain peanuts and tree nuts.


Star D Kosher CertificationKosher Certification “Download

NO rbst

We source our cream and milk from Ohio dairies, which certify that they are free of artificial growth hormones (rBST also known as rBGH). We think producing milk the way nature intended is better for everyone.

No significant difference has been shown between milk derived from rbst-treated and non-rbst treated cows.