Ice Cream Cakes & Pies

How do we make them so irresistible?

We take one of our freshly baked yellow or chocolate 8" round cakes and slice it through the middle. In between, we place over one pound of irresistible Graeter's ice cream. We finish it off with a layer of homemade topping and surround the sides with a gourmet blend frosting.

Our pies are made with a 9-inch chocolate graham cookie crust filled with nearly two pounds of our ice cream, capped with one of our homemade toppings and trimmed with a gourmet blend frosting. All cakes and pies will comfortably serve 10-12 people.

Download Our Brochure
Black Rasberry Chip Pie
Black Rasberry Chip Pie

Our Black Raspberry Chip Ice cream in a chocolate pie shell, topped with bittersweet chocolate and chocolate curls.

Buckeye Pie
Buckeye Pie

Creamy Peanut Butter Chip ice cream in a chocolate pie shell, topped with bittersweet chocolate and a buckeye candy in the center.

Turtle Pie
Turtle Pie

Our delicious Vanilla ice cream in a chocolate pie shell. Topped with our famous blend of bittersweet chocolate, butterscotch and pecans.


Black Raspberry Chocolate Bliss
Black Raspberry Chocolate Bliss

Black Raspberry Chip ice cream sandwiched between two layers of chocolate cake, topped with bittersweet chocolate and marshmallow.

Mint Chip Truffle
Mint Chip Truffle

Refreshing Mint Chocolate Chip ice cream sandwiched between two layers of chocolate cake, bittersweet topping and finished with a mint truffle on top.

Oreo Supreme
Oreo Supreme

Our classic Cookies & Cream ice cream sandwiched between chocolate cake, and topped with bittersweet and finished with an Oreo.


Celebration Favorite
Celebration Favorite

This cake is perfect for a special occasion. Featuring Vanilla ice cream, chocolate cake and bittersweet topping, this favorite will make everyone happy!

Chocolate Fantasy
Chocolate Fantasy

A cake for chocolate lovers! Double Chocolate Chip ice cream, chocolate cake, bittersweet topping and a special chocolate whipped topping.

Strawberry Shortcake
Strawberry Shortcake

Delectable Strawberry ice cream, sandwiched between yellow cake, with loads of real strawberry fruit and a special strawberry whipped topping.


Perfect Slice Serving Tips


1

Each cake or pie will serve around 12 people, depending on slice size.

2

Thaw in refrigerator for 40-45 mins. prior to serving. This will allow cake to moisten and ice cream to soften.

3

When cutting, remove cake from plastic tray and place on solid cutting surface. Heat large kitchen knife under hot water. Wipe blade dry between cuts.

4

Once finished, put leftovers back on tray with dome securely tightened and return to freezer. For best taste consume leftovers within a week.